Substitute
Miso Paste Substitute: 7 Swaps That Work, With Ratios
Miso is a fermented soybean paste that adds salt, savory depth and body to soups, marinades and dressings. If you have a different color of miso, use that. If you have none, soy sauce covers the salt and umami, and tahini mixed with soy sauce covers the body as well.
By Koji & Steel Published
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Picks are chosen first; links are added after. Learn more.
The short answer
For 1 tablespoon of miso paste, use 1 tablespoon of any other miso, or 2 teaspoons if you are replacing white miso with red. With no miso at all, use 1 1/2 teaspoons of soy sauce in soups, or 2 teaspoons of tahini mixed with 1 teaspoon of soy sauce in dressings and glazes.
Best miso paste substitutes, ranked
| Substitute | For 1 tablespoon miso paste | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| A different color of miso White, yellow, red and blended miso can all stand in for one another. Red is saltier and stronger, so use less of it. White is milder and sweeter, so you may need a pinch more salt. | 1 tbsp (2 tsp if using red in place of white) | Any recipe. The closest match. |
| Soy sauce Gives salt and umami but no body, so soups stay clear and sauces stay thin. Taste and add more a little at a time. | Start with 1 1/2 tsp (1/2 tbsp) | Soups, marinades and stir-fry sauces. |
| Tamari Use it exactly as you would soy sauce. Check the label if you need it to be gluten free. | Start with 1 1/2 tsp (1/2 tbsp) | The same uses as soy sauce, usually without wheat. |
| Tahini + soy sauce Tahini replaces the body and richness, and soy sauce the salt and umami. It adds a sesame flavor and is not a good fit for a clear miso soup. | 2 tsp tahini + 1 tsp soy sauce | Dressings, glazes and sauces. |
| Doenjang (Korean soybean paste) A fermented soybean paste like miso, but stronger, saltier and funkier. Start with less and build up. | 2 tsp | Hearty soups, stews and marinades. |
| Fish sauce Adds salt and savory depth with a clear fish note. It has none of miso's body or sweetness. | 1 tsp | Soups only. |
| Vegetable or dashi stock + salt For each tablespoon of miso left out, cook with stock instead of water and salt to taste. The result is a clear soup, not a miso soup. | Stock in place of the water + about 1/4 tsp salt | Soup when nothing else is on hand. |
What miso does in a recipe
Miso is a paste of soybeans fermented with salt and koji, usually grown on rice or barley. It brings five things to a dish:
- Salt. Miso is the main seasoning in miso soup and many marinades.
- Umami. Fermentation breaks the soybeans down into amino acids, which give miso its savory depth.
- Body. It is a thick paste. It clouds and enriches a soup, and it helps dressings and glazes cling.
- A slight sweetness. This comes from the koji, and it is most noticeable in white miso.
- Fermented aroma. The rounded, slightly funky smell that makes miso soup taste like miso soup.
Soy sauce gives you the first two. Tahini with soy sauce adds the third. Only another fermented soybean paste covers all five.
Which substitute for which dish
Miso soup. Another miso is the only swap that still gives miso soup. Use the same amount, or less if yours is darker than the recipe’s. Without miso, season the dashi with soy sauce, or with a small amount of fish sauce, and serve it as a clear soup.
Marinades and glazes. Miso clings to fish, chicken and vegetables and browns under heat. Tahini and soy sauce comes closest in texture. Doenjang works for stronger marinades. Soy sauce on its own will season the food but will not coat it.
Dressings and sauces. Tahini and soy sauce again, since the dressing needs something to thicken it. Add a splash of water if it turns stiff.
Stews, ramen broth and braises. Soy sauce, tamari or doenjang. There is enough going on in the pot that the missing body is less obvious. If soy sauce is the bottle you are out of, see our soy sauce substitutes.
Substituting for white miso
White miso (shiro miso) is the mildest and sweetest kind, with less salt than red miso. Recipes that name it, such as miso-glazed fish, dressings and some baking, are counting on that gentleness.
- Red or blended (awase) miso: use about 2 teaspoons for each tablespoon of white miso. In a sweet glaze or dressing, add a pinch of sugar.
- No miso at all: mix 2 teaspoons of tahini with 1/2 teaspoon of soy sauce and a pinch of sugar. This is the tahini mix from the table with half the soy sauce, to match white miso’s lower salt.
What not to use
Gochujang is a fermented paste too, but it is built on chile and sweet glutinous rice, so it brings heat and sweetness that miso does not have. Hoisin and oyster sauce are sweet, thick and strongly flavored. Plain salt replaces the saltiness and nothing else. Bouillon cubes add salt and savoriness to a soup, but their meat or vegetable flavor is easy to pick out.
Buying the real thing
Miso keeps for months in the fridge, so a tub is rarely wasted. If you cook Japanese food more than occasionally, one all-purpose miso covers most recipes. The three below span the range: a slow-aged red koji miso from Hikari sold in a large tub, a red and white awase blend from Miko for daily soup, and Hikari’s organic sweet white miso in the Kyoto Saikyo style, the kind used for miso-marinated fish. For the full list and how the styles differ, see our guide to the best miso paste.
Or keep the real thing on hand
If you cook Japanese food more than occasionally, a bottle of real miso paste is worth the shelf space. These are in stock now.
-
Hikari Kodawattemasu Additive-Free Miso · Hikari Miso
A slow-aged red koji miso made with organic soybeans and no additives or preservatives. A large tub of everyday, all-purpose miso.
Made in Japan · Nagano Curated and researched $$ -
Miko Awase Miso · Miyasaka Jozo (Miko brand)
A blend of red and white miso (awase) in a 500 g pack. A low-cost, middle-of-the-road miso for daily soup.
Made in Japan Curated and researched $ -
Hikari Organic Saikyo Sweet Miso · Hikari Miso
An organic sweet white miso in the Kyoto Saikyo style, which is lower in salt and higher in rice koji than standard white miso. The style used for miso-marinated fish.
Made in Japan · Nagano Curated and researched $$
Common questions
What can I use instead of miso paste?
Another color of miso is the best swap. Without any miso, use 1 1/2 teaspoons of soy sauce per tablespoon of miso in soups, or 2 teaspoons of tahini mixed with 1 teaspoon of soy sauce in dressings and glazes.
Can I substitute soy sauce for miso?
Yes, for the salt and umami. Start with 1 1/2 teaspoons of soy sauce for each tablespoon of miso and adjust to taste. Soy sauce is a thin liquid, so it will not thicken a sauce or cloud a soup the way miso does.
What can I use instead of white miso?
Use about 2 teaspoons of red or blended miso for each tablespoon of white miso, since they are saltier. With no miso, mix 2 teaspoons of tahini with 1/2 teaspoon of soy sauce and a pinch of sugar.
Can I use red miso instead of white miso?
Yes, but use about two thirds of the amount. Red miso is fermented longer and is saltier and stronger than white miso. In sweet marinades and dressings, a pinch of sugar helps make up for white miso's sweetness.
Can I make miso soup without miso paste?
You can make a good clear soup with dashi, tofu and seaweed seasoned with soy sauce and salt, but it will not taste like miso soup. Japanese cooking has its own name for clear soups of this kind, suimono.
Is there a soy-free substitute for miso?
Tahini with a pinch of salt replaces the body and saltiness without soy, and some makers sell miso made from chickpeas in place of soybeans. Soy sauce, tamari and doenjang all contain soy.
Keep reading
-
Buying guide
Best Miso Paste: White, Red, Hatcho and American-Made
Seven miso pastes worth buying, from sweet white Saikyo to dense hatcho and two American-made tubs, with which type to use for soup, marinades and glazes.
-
Substitute
Soy Sauce Substitute: 7 Swaps That Work, With Ratios
Out of soy sauce, or avoiding soy or gluten? Use tamari, liquid aminos or coconut aminos. Exact ratios for seven substitutes and which one fits your diet.