Skip to content
Koji & Steel

Substitute

Soy Sauce Substitute: 7 Swaps That Work, With Ratios

Soy sauce brings salt, savory depth and color to a dish in one pour. The closest substitute is tamari, used 1:1. If you are avoiding soy or gluten, coconut aminos is the usual answer, with a pinch of salt to make up the difference.

By Koji & Steel Published

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Picks are chosen first; links are added after. Learn more.

The short answer

For 1 tablespoon of soy sauce, use 1 tablespoon of tamari or liquid aminos. For a soy-free swap, use 1 tablespoon of coconut aminos plus a pinch of salt. Fish sauce works in cooked dishes: start with 1 to 2 teaspoons, because it is much saltier.

Best soy sauce substitutes, ranked

Substitute For 1 tablespoon soy sauce Best for
Tamari A Japanese soy sauce made with little or no wheat. Most bottles are gluten free, but not all, so check the label if that matters. 1 tbsp, used 1:1 Any recipe. The closest match.
Liquid aminos A seasoning made from soybeans without wheat. It looks and tastes close to soy sauce. It is not soy free. 1 tbsp, used 1:1 Stir-fries, marinades and dressings.
Coconut aminos Made from coconut palm sap and salt. It is sweeter and less salty than soy sauce, so add salt and cut back slightly on any sugar in the recipe. 1 tbsp + a pinch of salt Soy-free and gluten-free cooking.
Worcestershire sauce Tangier and spiced, with vinegar and tamarind. Most brands contain anchovy, so it is not vegetarian. Add salt to taste, since it is less salty than soy sauce. 1 tbsp Marinades, stews, burgers and other cooked Western dishes.
Fish sauce Much saltier, with a strong fish aroma that mellows with cooking. Start low, taste, and top up with water if the recipe needs the liquid. Start with 1 to 2 tsp Soups, stir-fries and cooked sauces.
Miso paste thinned with water Whisk until smooth. It is cloudy and thicker than soy sauce, so it is not for dipping. Miso contains soy, and some kinds contain barley. 1 tsp miso + 2 tsp water Soups, marinades and glazes.
Salt (last resort) Replaces the salt and the liquid only. There is no umami, color or aroma, so the dish will taste plainer. About 1/4 tsp salt + 1 tbsp water Any recipe where soy sauce is a minor seasoning.

What soy sauce does in a recipe

Soy sauce is brewed from soybeans, wheat, salt and water. It does four jobs at once:

  • Salt. It is the main seasoning in many Japanese dishes, standing in for table salt.
  • Umami. Fermentation breaks soy and wheat proteins down into amino acids, which give the savory depth that plain salt lacks.
  • Color. It turns sauces, braises and fried rice a reddish brown.
  • Aroma. Brewing produces a roasted, slightly sweet smell that comes forward when soy sauce hits a hot pan.

Tamari and liquid aminos cover all four. Each option further down the list drops at least one, and plain salt covers only the first.

Pick a substitute by what you need

You just ran out. Use tamari or liquid aminos 1:1. If neither is in the house, thin a little miso with water for soups and marinades. See our miso paste substitutes if you are short on that too.

Gluten free. Use a tamari that is labeled gluten free, or coconut aminos. Liquid aminos made from soybeans is usually wheat free as well, but confirm on the label. Regular soy sauce is not gluten free.

Soy free. Use coconut aminos with a pinch of salt. In cooked dishes, fish sauce plus a little salt and water also works. Tamari, liquid aminos and miso are all soy products.

Lower sodium. Buy a reduced-sodium soy sauce, or use coconut aminos and leave out the extra pinch of salt. Diluting regular soy sauce with water lowers the salt, and it thins the flavor too.

Vegetarian or vegan. Tamari, liquid aminos, coconut aminos and miso are all plant based. Fish sauce and most Worcestershire sauce are not.

Light, dark and Japanese soy sauce

“Light” and “dark” soy sauce are Chinese categories. Light soy sauce is the thin, salty everyday one. Dark soy sauce is thicker, darker and slightly sweet, and is added mostly for color.

Japanese soy sauce is sorted differently. Koikuchi, the standard dark-colored style, is the all-purpose default and is what a recipe means when it says only “soy sauce”. It can stand in 1:1 for Chinese light soy sauce. Japanese usukuchi is paler in color but saltier than koikuchi, so use a little less if you swap it in.

What not to use

Teriyaki sauce is soy sauce with sugar and other seasonings already added. Swapped 1:1, it makes a dish sweet. Oyster sauce and hoisin sauce are thick and sweet and behave more like a glaze than a seasoning liquid. A small spoonful of any of them can add savory depth to a stir-fry, but none works as a straight replacement.

Buying the real thing

For everyday cooking, the all-purpose koikuchi style is the bottle to keep. Among the picks below, the Kikkoman is a USDA-certified organic koikuchi listed as a product of Japan. The Kishibori Shoyu comes from Shodoshima and is aged over a year in wooden barrels. For a wheat-free bottle, the San-J tamari is brewed from 100 percent soy, and the Yamasan tamari is aged for two years in wooden barrels and listed as gluten free.

Or keep the real thing on hand

If you cook Japanese food more than occasionally, a bottle of real soy sauce is worth the shelf space. These are in stock now.

  • San-J Gluten Free Tamari · San-J

    A wheat-free tamari brewed from 100% soy by a family company with eight generations of tamari making. The easiest gluten-free soy sauce to find in the US.

    Made in USA · Virginia Curated and researched $$
  • Yamasan Cedar Barrel Aged Tamari · Yamasan Kyoto Uji

    A tamari fermented and aged for two years in wooden barrels, listed as gluten free. The maker describes it as thick, sweet and rich.

    Made in Japan Curated and researched $$
  • Kikkoman Organic Soy Sauce · Kikkoman

    A USDA-certified organic koikuchi listed as a product of Japan. A dependable everyday soy sauce for cooking.

    Made in Japan Curated and researched $
  • Takesan Kishibori Shoyu · Takesan

    A koikuchi soy sauce from Shodoshima made with whole soybeans, wheat and sun-dried salt, aged over a year in wooden barrels and slowly pressed.

    Made in Japan · Shodoshima Curated and researched $$

Common questions

What is the best substitute for soy sauce?

Tamari, used 1:1. It is a Japanese soy sauce made with little or no wheat, and it behaves the same way in cooking and as a dipping sauce. Liquid aminos, also used 1:1, is the next closest.

What is a gluten-free substitute for soy sauce?

Tamari that is labeled gluten free, used 1:1, or coconut aminos with a pinch of salt. Regular soy sauce is brewed with wheat and is not gluten free. Not every tamari is wheat free, so read the label.

What is a soy-free substitute for soy sauce?

Coconut aminos is the closest soy-free option: use 1 tablespoon plus a pinch of salt for each tablespoon of soy sauce. In cooked dishes, 1 to 2 teaspoons of fish sauce also works. Tamari, liquid aminos and miso all contain soy.

Can I use Worcestershire sauce instead of soy sauce?

Yes, in cooked dishes such as marinades and stews, at 1 tablespoon for 1 tablespoon. It is tangier, spiced and less salty, and most brands contain anchovy. It is a poor match for sushi or other dishes where soy sauce is tasted on its own.

Is tamari the same as soy sauce?

Tamari is a type of Japanese soy sauce. Regular soy sauce is brewed from roughly equal parts soybeans and wheat, while tamari uses mostly or only soybeans. The two can be swapped 1:1.

Can I use Japanese soy sauce when a recipe asks for light or dark soy sauce?

For light soy sauce, yes: standard Japanese soy sauce can be used 1:1. Chinese dark soy sauce is thicker, darker and slightly sweet and is used mainly for color, so Japanese soy sauce will season the dish but leave it paler.